I can’t remember how I actually learned most of the knitting techniques I’ve used since I was a teenager. My grandmother showed me the basic knit and purl stitch when I was about 13, and I’m guessing she also showed me the long-tail cast-on and how to close seams using single crochet. After that, I didn’t knit much until I was 16. I did join a “knitting club” in either 5th or 6th grade, but this simply meant going to another classroom on Friday afternoons and knitting. There was no requirement to pick a project and finish it, and I hazily recall that all I managed to accomplish was a giant swatch. Most of the time, I just fooled around with a friend—something I was prone to do in those days. In fact, all through grade school, I had the dubious distinction of being the girl with the worst behavior record in my class. Girls in the 1950s didn’t do that. We were supposed to be quiet, docile, and charming. By today’s standards, my infractions were tame—I talked out of turn, didn’t do the assigned work, and annoyed the people around me so they didn’t get their work done. I was mostly bored, and when I did get into programs that had more rigorous coursework, this behavior stopped. But back to knitting. So there was a gap between 13 and 16, during which I didn’t knit anything. When I resumed knitting at age 16 after buying wool for a bulky sweater that was considered cutting-edge fashion in the Bronx at that time, I had to reconstruct my knowledge from my grandmother’s lessons. She and my mother had stopped talking to one another, and there was no one to ask. So I bought a how-to-knit book and pressed on—and never really stopped knitting from that time on.
For a while, I considered that I misinterpreted the pictures in that how-to book. I’m now quite sure that my grandmother taught me to knit combined style because she came from eastern Russia. And so for years I knitted “incorrectly”—and I still do hold the yarn in an odd way, but that is a topic for another post. Being an untaught combined knitter did make me pay attention to stitch mounts and the direction of increases and decreases, so I think I had a better sense of what you are doing when you knit than my friends who learned Continental and English style knitting and could follow instructions more easily. But as for closing seams, I’ve never found any book that showed crocheted seams, and my grandmother was even more accomplished at crocheting than knitting. I’m sure, then, that she must have shown me this too. I crocheted my seams from the time I was 16 until just about five years ago, when I tried mattress stitch. Mattress stitch worked for me on heavy sweaters for my son, and I’ve used it on other sweaters, but I really like to crochet my seams closed because it makes such a firm and neat join.
In deciding how to work on Liv’s seams, I first tried to crochet using one loop on the edge stitch. This sometimes doesn’t produce a seam as neat as I’d like because it makes a ridge or shows a line going up the seam. And that happened. I then switched to mattress stitch, and the results didn’t look good. I wanted an invisible seam, and I was getting a blobby look at the join. It wasn’t invisible at all.
So I went back to crocheting, this time taking two threads on each side of the garment.
This photo, which was really hard for me to shoot, has the crochet hook under two loops (a full edge stitch) on one side of the seam.
The finished seam is about as thick as a three-needle bindoff, and you do see the join, but it blocks out nicely on Silky Wool and goes neatly up the sides of the sweater. I will reblock again when I'm done with all the seams to adjust the joins around the side increases and decreases so they're slightly straighter.
Another reason I like this style of seaming on Liv is that Silky Wool is very stretchy, and this gives the sweater some “bone structure”. If you crochet loosely enough, the seam doesn’t pucker or pull, and it forms a firm foundation for the sweater lines.
I managed to finish just one seam last night, but the sleeves are blocked, and I should be able to finish Liv completely in two more nights of knitting.